Mobile Version
|
Register
|
Login
home
|
speak out!
|
content zone archives
|
"speak out!" archives
|
vote on it
|
soap opera
|
pub crawl
|
links
|
contact us
|
search
Follow us!
Speak Out! - Other Sports
Notices
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
Yesterday's HOT topics
|
Today's HOT topics
| Jump to:
All Topics
Topic:
Irish team to wear black armbands
Frodo
(242 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 12:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Not sure about this and would be interested to hear the arguements one way or the other. In a week when the existance of deep rooted sectarianism is again confirmed in the north, 88 "peace walls" now in Belfast, and with the obvious antaganism towards the Irish soccer team from loyalist areas of the north is this not going to be seen as confirming the divide. I hope I hardly need to state my abhorrance of the act and that the families no doubt are acting with the best intentions but I am not sure if this is something the FAI should be involved in? Opinions?
stones_off
(2,815 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 12:48
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Frodo:
Not sure about this and would be interested to hear the arguements one way or the other. In a week when the existance of deep rooted sectarianism is again confirmed in the north, 88 "peace walls" now in Belfast, and with the obvious antaganism towards the Irish soccer team from loyalist areas of the north is this not going to be seen as confirming the divide. I hope I hardly need to state my abhorrance of the act and that the families no doubt are acting with the best intentions but I am not sure if this is something the FAI should be involved in? Opinions?
I am against black arm bands full stop. There will be somebody or some reason to wear one, every time you play. So picking a specific case, leaves you open to constant criticism.
JohnneyCool
(2,069 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 13:39
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by frasiercrane:
What are they wearing the balack armbands for.
Some D list celeb from D4 got coked out of their heads and died.
I think its only appropriate myself
LimerickExileInClare
(750 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 14:18
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Im sure that opinion on this particular issue will be very much divided.
I can vividly remember that horrific incident as I have an indirect association with Loughinisland.
That particular bar The Heights was seen as a Catholic Bar and tensions were very high at the time.
This attack,which was carriesd out by Loyalist gunmen, was believed to be in relatiation for the deaths of 3 UVF members by the INLA two days earlier in the Shankill in Belfast.
Six innocent people,including an 87 year old man,were gunned down while watching the Republic playing Italy on the 18th Jume 1994.
No earnest effort was made to identify the persons that carried out this deed, in fact a cloud of suspicion hangs over the whole investigative process that prevailed at the time - enough said as I dont want go to into anymore detail.
On a personal basis I welcome the gesture but I appreciate that other people may very well have a different view completely.
As some one who has more than a passing knowledge of the North I can categorically say that it will take more than few decades to eradicate the "deep rooted sectarianism" that exist at present.
There will always be antagonism against the Republic of Ireland soccer from Loyalist areas,watching RTE 2 Programme Green is The Colour last confirms that this has gone on for generations.
Its my personal opinion that the proposed gesture by the FAI,while it may not do too much for relations between the two soccer authorities in the Island,will not fuel the antagonism to any greater heights than it is at present.
I always feel that whatever hope that the Northern Ireland soccer team has of attracting "nationalist" support it will not succeed while is stadium is in the centre of one of the most staunchest loyalist in the North.
The Parting Gas
(158 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 16:39
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by LimerickExileInClare:
Im sure that opinion on this particular issue will be very much divided.
I can vividly remember that horrific incident as I have an indirect association with Loughinisland.
That particular bar The Heights was seen as a Catholic Bar and tensions were very high at the time.
This attack,which was carriesd out by Loyalist gunmen, was believed to be in relatiation for the deaths of 3 UVF members by the INLA two days earlier in the Shankill in Belfast.
Six innocent people,including an 87 year old man,were gunned down while watching the Republic playing Italy on the 18th Jume 1994.
No earnest effort was made to identify the persons that carried out this deed, in fact a cloud of suspicion hangs over the whole investigative process that prevailed at the time - enough said as I dont want go to into anymore detail.
On a personal basis I welcome the gesture but I appreciate that other people may very well have a different view completely.
As some one who has more than a passing knowledge of the North I can categorically say that it will take more than few decades to eradicate the "deep rooted sectarianism" that exist at present.
There will always be antagonism against the Republic of Ireland soccer from Loyalist areas,watching RTE 2 Programme Green is The Colour last confirms that this has gone on for generations.
Its my personal opinion that the proposed gesture by the FAI,while it may not do too much for relations between the two soccer authorities in the Island,will not fuel the antagonism to any greater heights than it is at present.
I always feel that whatever hope that the Northern Ireland soccer team has of attracting "nationalist" support it will not succeed while is stadium is in the centre of one of the most staunchest loyalist in the North.
In fairness, you're hardly giving away the third secret of Fatima here. This has been covered in some depth - the RUC had informers within the UVF who told them it was going to happen and they let it happen. When they retrieved the getaway car, they destroyed the fcuking thing shortly afterwards.
As I posted on another thread on this, the real gutless goons here were the FAI. Six of their own supporters slaughtered and there was no sign of any gesture of mourning. Yet they were quick to order the black armbands for Princess Diana's death in 1997. Craven shi'ites.
Saw that documentary on the history of Irish soccer last night. Truth be told, it was a bit crap, but when I heard that the IFA tried to stop the FAI getting Fifa recognition, it made me even happier that we're able to snaffle some of the best Northern-born players.
stones_off
(2,815 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 16:41
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by The Parting Gas:
Saw that documentary on the history of Irish soccer last night. Truth be told, it was a bit crap
I thought it was very good. Very interesting.
An Carta Bui
(277 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 18:24
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
The deep rooted sectarianism works both ways and despite what Adams and his gang claim it is as bad as ever with more peace walls now than in the 90s. Loughlinisland also showed the Provos that the Loyalist paramilitaries were going to continue hitting nationalists in retaliation for any attack on loyalists or security forces. It created a momentum that led to the Provos to realise that neither side was going to win militarily.
Big Phil
(575 Posts)
Posted:
17-May-2012 18:37
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by stones_off:
I thought it was very good. Very interesting.
Me too, will be tuning in for the remaining episodes. A programme of its kind was long overdue and good timing by RTE given the building euphoria around the Irish team at present.
JohnneyCool
(2,069 Posts)
Posted:
18-May-2012 10:07
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by An Carta Bui:
The deep rooted sectarianism works both ways and despite what Adams and his gang claim it is as bad as ever with more peace walls now than in the 90s. Loughlinisland also showed the Provos that the Loyalist paramilitaries were going to continue hitting nationalists in retaliation for any attack on loyalists or security forces. It created a momentum that led to the Provos to realise that neither side was going to win militarily.
It's as bad as ever, Are you for real? What are RTE and the Indo feeding you down there?
Granted its far from perfect, but I'd suggest you've more chance of getting shot in the cross fire of a drugs feud in Dublin than you are in Belfast or anywhere in the North.
Ozzy
(1,867 Posts)
Posted:
18-May-2012 22:14
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
The Irish soccer team wore black armbands to mark the death of Diana, so the FAI can hardly be accused of sectarianism now. If some people want to be offended by this; a team wearing black armbands to honour innocent people who were gunned down mercilessly, they're the ones with the problem. The FAI are not responsible.
I'd say Northern Ireland have missed their chance of attracting large scale Catholic support at this stage. Catholics can declare for the Republic easily now and that's what the better players are going to do. I know the authorities in the North don't like this, but there's no legitimacy to their complaints IMO. People in the North are entitled to Irish passports and citizenship,no reason they would want to represent a state they don't feel allegiance to.
greendolphin
(2,177 Posts)
Posted:
18-May-2012 23:02
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Ozzy:
The Irish soccer team wore black armbands to mark the death of Diana, so the FAI can hardly be accused of sectarianism now. If some people want to be offended by this; a team wearing black armbands to honour innocent people who were gunned down mercilessly, they're the ones with the problem. The FAI are not responsible.
I'd say Northern Ireland have missed their chance of attracting large scale Catholic support at this stage. Catholics can declare for the Republic easily now and that's what the better players are going to do. I know the authorities in the North don't like this, but there's no legitimacy to their complaints IMO. People in the North are entitled to Irish passports and citizenship,no reason they would want to represent a state they don't feel allegiance to.
Well said Ozzy.
Dench
(326 Posts)
Posted:
18-May-2012 23:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Ozzy:
The Irish soccer team wore black armbands to mark the death of Diana, so the FAI can hardly be accused of sectarianism now. If some people want to be offended by this; a team wearing black armbands to honour innocent people who were gunned down mercilessly, they're the ones with the problem. The FAI are not responsible.
I'd say Northern Ireland have missed their chance of attracting large scale Catholic support at this stage. Catholics can declare for the Republic easily now and that's what the better players are going to do. I know the authorities in the North don't like this, but there's no legitimacy to their complaints IMO. People in the North are entitled to Irish passports and citizenship,no reason they would want to represent a state they don't feel allegiance to.
That's exactly it. Could you imagine a nationalist young lad going out onto Windsor Park and they singing the shït they do. Probably not as bad as they used to be but you couldn't feel as though you were one of them
singing goalie
(397 Posts)
Posted:
18-May-2012 23:54
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
I drove past the Heights Bar recently. It hasn't changed at all from the tv footage of 1994. I have never had a pint in the place, but it looked aged in 94 on TV and like many bars hit in the troubles, it must feel tough to carry out extensive renovations now. Time moves on. 6 People watching an Ireland game were slaughtered whilst watching their team. The FAI could have done more sooner. 18 years later, on the same day, against the same Italian opposition is fitting. A good move in my opinion.
sub of the day
(521 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 07:31
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
We were in Giants Stadium for the historic win,and were still on a high, flying down to Orlando for the Mexico game, when a fellow passenger said, "did you guys see the news".To say we were shocked was an understatement.To think while we were watching the boys in green, six fellow fans were being gunned down in cold blood, was chilling.Given the date , and the opposition, ROI V ITALY June 18/1994/2012, I think the FAI have made the right call.I'm sure if they had chosen to turn a blind eye, a lot of the same people would be on their backs.
KeepOnHurling
(3,223 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 07:46
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Ozzy:
The Irish soccer team wore black armbands to mark the death of Diana,
Did they really? Don't remember that.
What other countries did that? Had Diana ever been to Ireland before?
Seems a bit over the top.
I think it's a fitting tribute, as the Italy game falls on the anniversary of the killing of Ireland fans.
As another poster said, if anybody has a problem with the FAI honouring 6 of its own supporters who were gunned down in cold blood while wastching their team, they are the ones with problems.
cerebus
(3,258 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 11:11
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
You can sing it!!
The Munster Lads have shown scant respect for all those unfairly and wrongly transported to van diemens land ,back in the day, they could at least wear some black velvet arm /hair bands.
frasiercrane
(1,843 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 12:07
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Irish Independent
19th May 2012
• What is the FAI thinking about? Black armbands for the game against Italy in Euro 2012! Loughinisland was just one of many atrocities on both sides of the divide in Northern Ireland, over a period of more than 30 years. It is far from unique in the context of the "Troubles".
It seems UEFA agreed after an approach by the FAI on behalf of the families.
John Delaney said: "It was more that the Irish team recognised this particular one as important given the significance of the date and the team we're playing."
Strangely, he followed this by saying he would be meeting some of the players to tell them the "reason and rationale" for this.
Will this mean, for example, that for future internationals against Northern Ireland, the Republic will be obliged to don black armbands at the request of the IFA and the relatives of those killed at Kingsmill, or Enniskillen, or any one of numerous other atrocities perpetrated by republicans. Dates or coincidence are neither here nor there.
To me, and I am sure many others, this kind of politically inspired nonsense has no place at Euro 2012 or any other sporting event. I sincerely hope the players tell Mr Delaney what to do with his "reason and rationale".
Niall Ginty
Killester, Dublin 5
ProjX
(726 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 12:12
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by frasiercrane:
Irish Independent
19th May 2012• What is the FAI thinking about? Black armbands for the game against Italy in Euro 2012! Loughinisland was just one of many atrocities on both sides of the divide in Northern Ireland, over a period of more than 30 years. It is far from unique in the context of the "Troubles".It seems UEFA agreed after an approach by the FAI on behalf of the families.John Delaney said: "It was more that the Irish team recognised this particular one as important given the significance of the date and the team we're playing."Strangely, he followed this by saying he would be meeting some of the players to tell them the "reason and rationale" for this.Will this mean, for example, that for future internationals against Northern Ireland, the Republic will be obliged to don black armbands at the request of the IFA and the relatives of those killed at Kingsmill, or Enniskillen, or any one of numerous other atrocities perpetrated by republicans. Dates or coincidence are neither here nor there.To me, and I am sure many others, this kind of politically inspired nonsense has no place at Euro 2012 or any other sporting event. I sincerely hope the players tell Mr Delaney what to do with his "reason and rationale".Niall Ginty
Killester, Dublin 5
I agree with the letter writer. It is a bad idea to wear these black armbands.
Surely if any team was to wear black armbands, it would be Northern Ireland? Why do they keep wanting to include the ROI in their conflict?
John Collins
(548 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 15:29
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
I wonder would Niall be as vicifourous if it was some thing with an Imperial element that was being commemerated. We have lads up in the six counties jumping up and down in every second village every 12 July, and several other days in the Summer, celebrating a squabble that took place 321 fcuking years ago. And we have fellows down here get into a twist over a black bit of crepe worn once in a lifetime to rightly remind us that a band of cowards shot six unarmed men dead because they were watching a team these thugs did not like, including an 85 yearr old man. And by way the IRA were cowards as well thats why Enniskillen, Omagh and other atrocities should be commemerated as well.
The Parting Gas
(158 Posts)
Posted:
19-May-2012 18:21
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by frasiercrane:
Irish Independent
19th May 2012• What is the FAI thinking about? Black armbands for the game against Italy in Euro 2012! Loughinisland was just one of many atrocities on both sides of the divide in Northern Ireland, over a period of more than 30 years. It is far from unique in the context of the "Troubles".It seems UEFA agreed after an approach by the FAI on behalf of the families.John Delaney said: "It was more that the Irish team recognised this particular one as important given the significance of the date and the team we're playing."Strangely, he followed this by saying he would be meeting some of the players to tell them the "reason and rationale" for this.Will this mean, for example, that for future internationals against Northern Ireland, the Republic will be obliged to don black armbands at the request of the IFA and the relatives of those killed at Kingsmill, or Enniskillen, or any one of numerous other atrocities perpetrated by republicans. Dates or coincidence are neither here nor there.To me, and I am sure many others, this kind of politically inspired nonsense has no place at Euro 2012 or any other sporting event. I sincerely hope the players tell Mr Delaney what to do with his "reason and rationale".Niall Ginty
Killester, Dublin 5
I haven't been reading the Indo's letters page of late, but I sincerely hope that someone responded to point out to this blinkered fcukwit that those killed at Loughlinisland were OUR supporters.
I'd love to see him try to explain his logic to the families of the victims. Kunt.
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
‘We talk just like lions, but we sacrifice like lambs…’.
Whatever Happened to….
Anyone you know in your club?
Bin Tags Don't Make a County
‘Some a’ Dem’ Lads are only Dow-en for the Showers….’
Heavenly Hurling: How the Gods pass their time...
GAA Time and Real Time
Saint Patrick and the camogie princesses
Keats and Chapman at the Munster Final
Mass, the Mater, ‘The Dergvale’ and Mullingar…
More "Content Zone" Topics >>
More "Speak Out!" Topics >>