Mobile Version
|
Register
|
Login
home
|
speak out!
|
content zone archives
|
"speak out!" archives
|
vote on it
|
soap opera
|
pub crawl
|
links
|
contact us
|
search
Follow us!
Speak Out! - Other Sports
Notices
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
Yesterday's HOT topics
|
Today's HOT topics
| Jump to:
All Topics
First
1
2
3
4
Last
Select a page:
1
2
3
4
PageSize:
10
25
50
Page
1
of
4
Topic:
Roy Keanes Comments
HangSanwich
(39 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:08
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
ROY KEANE lashed out at the Irish team last night following their 4-0 thrashing by Spain saying: "We’re a small country, we’re up against it, but let’s not just go along for the sing-song every now and again."
For once the mayfield man speaks sense.Granted the fans were the highlight of last night, as a nation we have to change our attitude,we have to go and compete.It has to start grass roots though at under age level and develop young players to pass and keep possession.
Lumpin the ball forward is not working which was clearly seen last night and last sunday.
John Delaney get the finger out and give us a team to be proud of.It might take bout 30 years to develop a reputable Irish team but if it does so be it.
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:14
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
He was never the same after Triggs passed on.
Paddy
(1,022 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:14
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Yea maybe so but that wasn't the time to start that rant about the fans. I'd rather hear them singing acting with dignity than carrying on Like the Polish & Russian fans.
Roy Keane has a massive chip on his shoulder about everything in life if you ask me.
He had his chance & walked away
barney stintson
(46 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:20
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Roy socking it to the FAI again, what a guy. Come back Roy, manage us, we need you.
Fr Murphys Ghost
(967 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:44
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
So basically Keane is having a go at the supporters for doing what they are supposed to do, support.
What a tit, i wouldnt have an issue with Keane having a go at the players or the manager, thats fair enough but he is having a go at the same people who put him on a pedestal and paid for the lifestyle he currently lives just like he did at Utd before.
Roy Keane, great player but a failed manager who walked out on his country on the biggest stage of all.
barney stintson
(46 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:45
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Fr Murphys Ghost:
So basically Keane is having a go at the supporters for doing what they are supposed to do, support.
You are so wrong. So so wrong.
carryharry
(4,804 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 09:57
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
There are 2 normal ways to react to Roy Keanes comments and both are correct,
1, Why would Roy feel the need to be ironic when he says the fans shouldn't just go for a sing a long? Roy went to a certain World Cup to play soccer and not cast an eye over the training etc!
2, The Irish fans singing last night after a 4-0 trashing did nothing only massage Trapp's ego. Ok we are limited in players compared to Spain but our formation played into their hands big time also. A good shot of booing imo would have being no harm and would have let Trap know that a performance like last nights was not good enough.
Their looked to be no plan to halt Spain at all which was most disappointing imo.
A clueless effort.
P.S The Irish fans should be proud of themselves for their support, but at the end of the day we are out. Not a celebration time imo.
Boston Bruin
(131 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:27
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Keane has a point. The more this week has gone on the more cringe worthy the whole thing has become, where we have completely reverted to the stereotypical novelty act everyone expects us to be resulting in predictable patronising comments from the likes of the English commentators. We are like the child allowed into his parents dinner party for the first half hour, where their friends can admire and be amused by his cuteness & childish innocence. Then abruptly, he is ushered up the stairs to bed as the guests sit down to their starters as the serious, grown up conversations begin or in our case the serious football. And whats worse , as all the tales of tomfoolery, gombeenism and high jinks emerge from Poznan and Gdansk through the papers, You Tube etc, it seems nobody finds this more amusing than ourselves. We think we are hilarious, and that everyone else thinks we are hilarious. It’s become embarrassing.
Sledgehammer
(459 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:39
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Boston Bruin:
Keane has a point. The more this week has gone on the more cringe worthy the whole thing has become, where we have completely reverted to the stereotypical novelty act everyone expects us to be resulting in predictable patronising comments from the likes of the English commentators. We are like the child allowed into his parents dinner party for the first half hour, where their friends can admire and be amused by his cuteness & childish innocence. Then abruptly, he is ushered up the stairs to bed as the guests sit down to their starters as the serious, grown up conversations begin or in our case the serious football. And whats worse , as all the tales of tomfoolery, gombeenism and high jinks emerge from Poznan and Gdansk through the papers, You Tube etc, it seems nobody finds this more amusing than ourselves. We think we are hilarious, and that everyone else thinks we are hilarious. It’s become embarrassing.
Yep I kind of agree.
On Roy, well he had a point in fairness, I would prefer if someone else was making it though
ToWinJustOnce
(330 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:44
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Boston Bruin:
Keane has a point. The more this week has gone on the more cringe worthy the whole thing has become, where we have completely reverted to the stereotypical novelty act everyone expects us to be resulting in predictable patronising comments from the likes of the English commentators. We are like the child allowed into his parents dinner party for the first half hour, where their friends can admire and be amused by his cuteness & childish innocence. Then abruptly, he is ushered up the stairs to bed as the guests sit down to their starters as the serious, grown up conversations begin or in our case the serious football. And whats worse , as all the tales of tomfoolery, gombeenism and high jinks emerge from Poznan and Gdansk through the papers, You Tube etc, it seems nobody finds this more amusing than ourselves. We think we are hilarious, and that everyone else thinks we are hilarious. It’s become embarrassing.
Exactly. Spot on. The 'Shur we're always laughing in Ireland' brigade will always exist, and in a way, fair play to them... but we are there to compete. And we didn't.
Roy Keane has the guts to say what is right. He doesn't care about what you or I think about him, and that should be admired. If you don't agree with him, fair enough, but at least he doesn't go along with this 'gallant losers' tripe.
And he wasn't having a go at the supporters per se, it was a dig at the attitude that allows us to not care about the result. The happy-go-lucky gombeens of Europe...
That was some support last night - fantastic - Bill said it was somewhat emotional - and it was. But we need to draw the line somewhere. Are we happy with our lot? We got there, that's enough.... Is it?
POS
(151 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:55
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
He's spot on.
Ireland as a nation needs to move on from celebrating mediocrity.
bluesky
(559 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:55
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
he is a bitter man, see he was with utv licking england arse
before games
Rebel CNC
(4,232 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 10:59
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Keane has a point re the attitude of "ah shur pity about result but shur aren't we a great oul' bunch of fans all the same". Although as previous poster pointed out, it is ironic coming from a guy that shafted his country because he went into a hissy fit.
As for players, poor performance but squad is limited. Fergie, Mourinho and Wenger together might have achieved a 2-0 beating rather than a 4-0 thrashing but the players are simply lower premiership or npower level journeymen and grafters and a few lads who though good in their time have left their best days well behind them.
Germany, Swedan and even Austria will not worry about meeting us in wc qualifiers even if new manager puts McClean, Coleman, McCarthy,Hoolahan, Ireland up against them.
stones_off
(2,815 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:02
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Is this the same Roy Keane who was complaining about Man Utd fans not supporting their team, calling them prawn sandwich eaters.
What does he want the supporters to do, rip up their seats and start throwing them onto the field.
All the supporter knew we had no chance. We over achieved qualifying. People who say we are happy losers are delusional, the reality is our players are not good. Our team was better in 2010, but it wasn't that good then either.
Roy Keane played with Ireland for 14 years, and never once even qualified for the European Championships.
We haven't had a player that would have gotten in the Spanish team since Liam Brady.
Our kids aren't going to get any better if they are continually watching the Premiership, with its long ball tactics.
barney stintson
(46 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:09
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by stones_off:
Is this the same Roy Keane
Do you know another Roy Keane?
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:11
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by stones_off:
.Our kids aren't going to get any better if they are continually watching the Premiership, with its long ball tactics.
It's not that simple. If you have the players it can be done. Chelsea won the Big One executing it to a T, and beating the unbeatable Barca along the way!
srb
(49 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:13
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
A cretin of the highest order and a horrible human being. This is the man-child who done a runner home from Saipan because he didn't fancy it. That performance wasn't a disgrace/embarrassing or that, Macedonia was, Cyprus away was, San Marino away was to name a few.
This group of players were punching above their weight to even get there so what if it all goes to the wall as it has done, the luck runs out, we so what? In a country blighted by recession, emigration and hopelessness, this past week or two has given people something to cheer, enjoy and feel proud of who they are. The fans at the end of the 2 games singing was merely an act of defiance in that we can't be broken.
Keane lives a millionaires lifestyle with little in common with the average man in the street, a product of the EPL monster he helped create.
The players did their best but they are several levels below what we face in this tournament and no amount of tactics, formations or attitude will change that. We were lucky to be there and may not be back for a long long time so why not just enjoy it for what it is, don't listen to begrudgers and get behind the team.
jaorta
(561 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:18
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by HangSanwich:
ROY KEANE lashed out at the Irish team last night following their 4-0 thrashing by Spain saying: "We’re a small country, we’re up against it, but let’s not just go along for the sing-song every now and again."For once the mayfield man speaks sense.Granted the fans were the highlight of last night, as a nation we have to change our attitude,we have to go and compete.It has to start grass roots though at under age level and develop young players to pass and keep possession.Lumpin the ball forward is not working which was clearly seen last night and last sunday.John Delaney get the finger out and give us a team to be proud of.It might take bout 30 years to develop a reputable Irish team but if it does so be it.
Roy Keane is a sad sad man reduced to prostituting himself for his british media masters and is best ignored....
Bejaysis
(4 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Last night wasn’t a case of the Irish fans cheering mediocrity.
The Irish fans are smart enough. Like everyone else, they knew that this Irish team wasn’t in the same class as the Spanish team.
They went with the blind optimism that fans always have, and saw the team try damn hard but come up miles short.
Fair enough there were individual errors, but the team still worked hard over the 90 mins. The fans cheered the team because they appreciate their efforts and realise that qualifying was an achievement in itself.
Everyone is disappointed but there is no shame in this limited Irish team losing to a great Spain team. It would have been disgraceful for the Irish fans to boo the efforts of the team, and it was not the place to make a statement against the management/style of play.
Our performances on the pitch didn’t win the hearts of any neutrals but our fans certainly did.
There is nothing embarrassing or ‘gombeen’ about that.
Bejaysis
(4 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:20
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by srb:
A cretin of the highest order and a horrible human being. This is the man-child who done a runner home from Saipan because he didn't fancy it. That performance wasn't a disgrace/embarrassing or that, Macedonia was, Cyprus away was, San Marino away was to name a few.
This group of players were punching above their weight to even get there so what if it all goes to the wall as it has done, the luck runs out, we so what? In a country blighted by recession, emigration and hopelessness, this past week or two has given people something to cheer, enjoy and feel proud of who they are. The fans at the end of the 2 games singing was merely an act of defiance in that we can't be broken.
Keane lives a millionaires lifestyle with little in common with the average man in the street, a product of the EPL monster he helped create.
The players did their best but they are several levels below what we face in this tournament and no amount of tactics, formations or attitude will change that. We were lucky to be there and may not be back for a long long time so why not just enjoy it for what it is, don't listen to begrudgers and get behind the team.
Well said :)
Rebel CNC
(4,232 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:21
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by srb:
The players did their best but they are several levels below what we face in this tournament and no amount of tactics, formations or attitude will change that. We were lucky to be there and may not be back for a long long time so why not just enjoy it for what it is, don't listen to begrudgers and get behind the team.
Good point. Can't se us qualifying for wc 2014 but with Euro 2016 expanded to 24 teams, even our bunch of journeyman grafters should qualify.
Boston Bruin
(131 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:29
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
In a way it’s hard to explain how we are not producing a higher proportion of all round talented players. 88 and 90 was a springboard for the game in this country and led to the evolution of a structured framework of coaching and player development by the FAI. We now have coaches all over the country , academies, centres of excellence plus a better, more scientific approach in terms of small sided games as opposed to 11 v 11 , more emphasis on physical preparation and technique etc, etc. However 25 years on, I’d argue that the team of 88/90 is certainly more technically gifted than the one that went out last night. Paul McGrath, gifted centre half, could play just as comfortable in centre mid, Ronnie Whelan, Liverpool’s playmaker could pick a pass and make things happen and remember the goal against the Soviets, Morris & Hughton as fullbacks were comfortable on the ball, even Quinn, for a big fella had good touch was could play on the deck. The home grown lads like Quinn, McGrath, Whelan and Brady before them all came through the Dublin Schoolboy nurseries who at that time had poor facilities so where these lads learned to play was on the street. So if 25 years on and after investing a whole pile of cash into player development & coaching means we are technically inferior to where we were in 88/90, then there is something seriously wrong with the methodology being used.
stones_off
(2,815 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:39
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Boston Bruin:
In a way it’s hard to explain how we are not producing a higher proportion of all round talented players. 88 and 90 was a springboard for the game in this country and led to the evolution of a structured framework of coaching and player development by the FAI. We now have coaches all over the country , academies, centres of excellence plus a better, more scientific approach in terms of small sided games as opposed to 11 v 11 , more emphasis on physical preparation and technique etc, etc. However 25 years on, I’d argue that the team of 88/90 is certainly more technically gifted than the one that went out last night. Paul McGrath, gifted centre half, could play just as comfortable in centre mid, Ronnie Whelan, Liverpool’s playmaker could pick a pass and make things happen and remember the goal against the Soviets, Morris & Hughton as fullbacks were comfortable on the ball, even Quinn, for a big fella had good touch was could play on the deck. The home grown lads like Quinn, McGrath, Whelan and Brady before them all came through the Dublin Schoolboy nurseries who at that time had poor facilities so where these lads learned to play was on the street. So if 25 years on and after investing a whole pile of cash into player development & coaching means we are technically inferior to where we were in 88/90, then there is something seriously wrong with the methodology being used.
I think you answered your own question there. It's all about tactics now with underage teams, and very little about skill.
Rebel CNC
(4,232 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:40
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Boston Bruin:
....The home grown lads like Quinn, McGrath, Whelan and Brady before them all came through the Dublin Schoolboy nurseries who at that time had poor facilities so where these lads learned to play was on the street. So if 25 years on and after investing a whole pile of cash into player development & coaching means we are technically inferior to where we were in 88/90, then there is something seriously wrong with the methodology being used.
It'a good point BB and applies to English too - for all the investment and resources poured into their academies by big clubs, they're not producing the Nevilles, the Gerrards, the Fowlers, Le Tissiers, Shearers, Scholes' or Giggs' they were producing 15 or 20 years ago.
Scottish football has also regressed massively since young lads moved from streets and muddy pitches to state of the art all weather pitches and fully kitted gyms, etc
Think we are bad - compare the Scottish team in 1978 or 86 world cup to dross that failed to qualify for euro 2012
N16
(1,724 Posts)
Posted:
15-Jun-2012 11:43
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Solving the problem with the irish soccer squad will take a generation. There are a lot of factors into that - young Irish lads are getting less of a chance in England these days with all the young foreign players being snapped up from Europe and Africa. And on top of that, I have serious reservations about coacing structures in England and Ireland. One thing they are doing in England now is reducing the number of players in games for u13s so that the kids have more time on the ball. vIt was typically met with derision from some quarters but its a no brainer for me. I play 5 a side with an Iraqi coach who has revolutionary ideas about coaching kids - but he has met a lot of resistance from English coaches who are happy with the status quo. So in this country you end up with the same bog standard players - all grit, all action but little flair or skill. England and Ireland will never produce a Messi or Xavi or David Siilva while this status quo remains in place. And even if work is done to change everything (in particular attitudes of older coaches who are responsible for a lot of the failure at international level), it will still take 20 years or so before the results would be seen. And that is the sorry situation we are in - countries like Spain and germany have moved on to another level and we're back worse than we wre 20 years ago.
Keane definately has a point. That team alst night as well as lacking quality in every sector just didnt work hard enough with our without the ball and got justly murdered.
As for the fans - fair play to them. The singing at the end was great, people like RVP and Fabrice Muamba even tweeted as much. That is proper support and they did the country pruod with their singing at the end. For many of those people it will be the trip of a lifetime, they'll never do anything like it again. So they are right to make the most of it, even if it is a total shambles on the pitch.
First
1
2
3
4
Last
Select a page:
1
2
3
4
Page
1
of
4
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
‘We talk just like lions, but we sacrifice like lambs…’.
Whatever Happened to….
Anyone you know in your club?
Bin Tags Don't Make a County
‘Some a’ Dem’ Lads are only Dow-en for the Showers….’
Heavenly Hurling: How the Gods pass their time...
GAA Time and Real Time
Saint Patrick and the camogie princesses
Keats and Chapman at the Munster Final
Mass, the Mater, ‘The Dergvale’ and Mullingar…
More "Content Zone" Topics >>
More "Speak Out!" Topics >>