Mobile Version  |  Register  |  Login
home  |  speak out!  |  content zone archives  |  "speak out!" archives  |  vote on it  |  soap opera  |  pub crawl  |  links  |  contact us  |  search  
 Follow us! 
Speak Out! - Other Topics
Notices
"Speak Out!" Home  |  Topic Listing  |  Post New Topic  |  Post Reply
Yesterday's HOT topics  |  Today's HOT topics
 |  Jump to:  
First 1 2 Last
Select a page:   PageSize:   Page 1 of 2
Topic: Irish dole and welfare payments are too high, warns IMF
Hurling Expert
(113 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 17:38
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
SOCIAL welfare benefits are too high in Ireland and need to be revised to encourage people back to work, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has said.

The organisation warned that dole payments are high by international standards and responsible for "low exit rates" from the Live Register.

As the IMF forecast the economy to grow by just 0.5pc this year, it said that certain welfare payments should be means-tested to avoid long-term unemployment.

The organisation - one of three bodies overseeing Ireland's €64.5bn euro bailout - suggested people out of work should be willing to take jobs regardless of suitability.

"It is also important to ensure that jobseekers are willing and able to fill jobs when they become available," it said.

IMF Ireland mission chief Craig Beaumont suggested that eligibility for child benefits should be narrowed, targeting only families that are "relatively less well-off".

He described child benefits as an expensive part of the social welfare budget and suggested limiting the number of medical cards issued.

Mr Beaumont pointed out that as people are living longer, the Government will otherwise be forced to hand out more and more of the cards.

"The cost of those medical cards will keep on rising. One way you can contain that is to look to some means-testing on eligibility," said Mr Beaumont.

The IMF bosses also praised the Government - for its implementation of the Croke Park Agreement, its €2.25bn stimulus plan announced yesterday and its continued work to meet its debt repayment targets.

Mr Beaumont said the Croke Park Agreement - a pact between the Government and public sector workers aimed at protecting jobs while scaling back resources - had made significant savings.

"It has been done in a way which has enabled public services to be protected and for gains to be achieved," said Mr Beaumont.

"There will be a need to continue to monitor those savings and make sure service provision is monitored going forward."

He added that Government plans to fund new public infrastructure projects - in roads, schools, health services and justice - with money from the European Investment Bank, National Pension Reserve Fund and sale of state assets would further benefit the economy.

The chief also pointed out the off balance sheet stimulus plan would have a "comparatively small" budgetary impact.
Limerick Rake
(257 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:25
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
A cap of 25,000 Euro should be placed on a Houses Social welfare with Childrens allowance only paid for first three kids....the situation now with Traveller famalies with ten & twelve children pulling in up to 100,000 with all the benefits..dole..childs all...carers allowance etc etc is breaking the country...no wonder none of them want to work....or travel for that matter
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:29
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply

Another good kicking coming up for the easy targets, methinks?

glasandbán
(2,046 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:31
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Yep, traveller families with too many children, thats what's breaking the country alright. Nothing to do with those bank debts we assumed or the "developers" who will never pay their debts either. If we could just sort out those traveller families we'd be flying it altogether.
rebelrebel30
(8,531 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:31
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Limerick Rake:
A cap of 25,000 Euro should be placed on a Houses Social welfare with Childrens allowance only paid for first three kids....the situation now with Traveller famalies with ten & twelve children pulling in up to 100,000 with all the benefits..dole..childs all...carers allowance etc etc is breaking the country...no wonder none of them want to work....or travel for that matter

How do you equate a taxpayer funded radio station paying someone 300K for 10 hours work a week?....
How do you equate someone who is essentially bust but receives 200K a year from the taxpayer to live on?
How do you equate Bank salarys and bonus of 500K in a bank bailed out by the taxpayer
How do you equate 100k a year earnings for politicans in a country of 4M?

I could go on and on and on...

Dublin_Ultra
(362 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:32
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
I would support a reduction in welfare benefits such as jobseekers (which would affect me) but only if public sector pay is attacked as well. The reforms and savings achived by Croke Park Agreement should have been achieved under benchmarking. Increments are slowly briniging salary levels up to pre-CPA levels. When the HSE have to make €300m savings over the next few months the savings will have to come from the remaining 20% that is not used up on salaries which means more pain and misery.
All budget corrections like this will have to do the same, salaries/staff numbers are untouchable. I imagine the founding fathers of the union movement in Ireland must roll over in their graves at the idea that the vulnerable will suffer while the unions threaten mass chaos to protect exorbitant wages during a recession



bp
(2,408 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:33
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply

Should social welfare be subject to a tax/levy when it passes a certain threshold ?

It must get very frustrating for a working man, who is busting his ball-ox getting out there and paying bills, to have to come home and turn on the radio to hear some waster who has no intention of working boasting about how much better off he is by being "a stay at home dad" and virtually ridiculing anyone who doesn't do the same.
Cheesus
(89 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:41
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
How much is paid out each year in rent allowance? The dole is enough.
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:44
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by bp:

Should social welfare be subject to a tax/levy when it passes a certain threshold ?It must get very frustrating for a working man, who is busting his ball-ox getting out there and paying bills, to have to come home and turn on the radio to hear some waster who has no intention of working boasting about how much better off he is by being "a stay at home dad" and virtually ridiculing anyone who doesn't do the same.

What radio station was all that broadcast on?

glasandbán
(2,046 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:44
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Cheesus:
How much is paid out each year in rent allowance? The dole is enough.

We should elect you boss, you'd sort em out.
bp
(2,408 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:50
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Hitch:
What radio station was all that broadcast on?

4 FM,

Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 18:58
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by bp:
4 FM,

Is that the one the mayor of Naas bogged himself on?

dubliner 2
(10,823 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 19:00
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Dublin_Ultra:
I would support a reduction in welfare benefits such as jobseekers (which would affect me) but only if public sector pay is attacked as well. The reforms and savings achived by Croke Park Agreement should have been achieved under benchmarking. Increments are slowly briniging salary levels up to pre-CPA levels. When the HSE have to make €300m savings over the next few months the savings will have to come from the remaining 20% that is not used up on salaries which means more pain and misery.
All budget corrections like this will have to do the same, salaries/staff numbers are untouchable. I imagine the founding fathers of the union movement in Ireland must roll over in their graves at the idea that the vulnerable will suffer while the unions threaten mass chaos to protect exorbitant wages during a recession

I don't accept that. I've made the point on here before, one that is easily checkable on the Department's own website, that a mrried man, unemployed with two kids gets over €22,000 in direct benefits a year. For a forty hour week that equates to €10.57, €2 more than the minimum wage and there are plenty of people out there working for that money. The idea that a household where no one works should be better off than one where someone is working for even €10 an hour (and paying tax) is laughable.

I see it the opposite way. As someone who is working I will accept a pay cut as long as social welfare is tackled. Child benefit for the rich (any household bringing in over €40,000 a year) is laughable. I also want to see pensions slashed. Two colleagues who recently retired will be pulling in not much less than I'll be earning next year for sitting on their arses. Not on.

There are about 291,000 public servants. Well over half earn less than €50,000 a year. I do not consider that to be an exhorbitant wage. But the ones at the top, social welfare and pensions all need to be tackled before those bringing home €35,000 a year or less are touched again.
glasandbán
(2,046 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 19:09
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by dubliner 2:
I don't accept that. I've made the point on here before, one that is easily checkable on the Department's own website, that a mrried man, unemployed with two kids gets over €22,000 in direct benefits a year. For a forty hour week that equates to €10.57, €2 more than the minimum wage and there are plenty of people out there working for that money. The idea that a household where no one works should be better off than one where someone is working for even €10 an hour (and paying tax) is laughable.

Doesn't the person on minimum wage also get child benefit?

You're duking the stats!
Deiseallstar
(69 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 19:10
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Isint it interesting that no one comes up with a recomendation to cut the wages of the big boys, those in the C.I.F Ibec, Senior Civil Servants, Bank Managers,Political Advisors that no one voted for, Failed ministers and TDs who bailed out with massive pensions and hand outs.
No calls to have our so called public Representavies who have no power or money reined in, yet they can pocket Hundrets of Thousants of Euro in wages and expences for their greedy selfs. My County Council Forked out 640.0000 between 23 Lazy Buggers last year you can multiply that by another id say 40 Local Authoritys and and see the cost of our so called political process.
We had another promise from FG/Lab to abolish the white elephant they called the senate but they backed off as if their arse were on fire.
No its easier to call for cuts in social welfare.or cut backs on the medical card as most of the above will never be so poor to qualify for either.
But bet your bottom dollar they will look for it anyway Its a rotten old Country we are now living in.
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 19:35
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Deiseallstar:
Isint it interesting that no one comes up with a recomendation to cut the wages of the big boys, those in the C.I.F Ibec, Senior Civil Servants, Bank Managers,Political Advisors that no one voted for, Failed ministers and TDs who bailed out with massive pensions and hand outs.
No calls to have our so called public Representavies who have no power or money reined in, yet they can pocket Hundrets of Thousants of Euro in wages and expences for their greedy selfs. My County Council Forked out 640.0000 between 23 Lazy Buggers last year you can multiply that by another id say 40 Local Authoritys and and see the cost of our so called political process.
We had another promise from FG/Lab to abolish the white elephant they called the senate but they backed off as if their arse were on fire.
No its easier to call for cuts in social welfare.or cut backs on the medical card as most of the above will never be so poor to qualify for either.
But bet your bottom dollar they will look for it anyway Its a rotten old Country we are now living in.

+1

...and when they compare us to other countries they never mention the lower cost of living in those other countries!

But here is the little pat on the head for Kenny, Gilmore, Noonan and Howlin and the mandarins:

..."The IMF bosses also praised the Government - for its implementation of the Croke Park Agreement, its €2.25bn stimulus plan announced yesterday and its continued work to meet its debt repayment targets."

let it long
(1,214 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 20:51
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Deiseallstar:
Isint it interesting that no one comes up with a recomendation to cut the wages of the big boys, those in the C.I.F Ibec, Senior Civil Servants, Bank Managers,Political Advisors that no one voted for, Failed ministers and TDs who bailed out with massive pensions and hand outs.
No calls to have our so called public Representavies who have no power or money reined in, yet they can pocket Hundrets of Thousants of Euro in wages and expences for their greedy selfs. My County Council Forked out 640.0000 between 23 Lazy Buggers last year you can multiply that by another id say 40 Local Authoritys and and see the cost of our so called political process.
We had another promise from FG/Lab to abolish the white elephant they called the senate but they backed off as if their arse were on fire.
No its easier to call for cuts in social welfare.or cut backs on the medical card as most of the above will never be so poor to qualify for either.
But bet your bottom dollar they will look for it anyway Its a rotten old Country we are now living in.

But its in their contract don't you know and you can't change a contract! Even in negociating the next one. These guys are just to valuble to mess around.

ProjX
(726 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 21:24
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Dole people should get nothing after 3 months on the dole.

Why cannot Dole people get a job after 3 months, when there are so many available jobs?

Apparently most illegals here are employed. What's wrong with the Dole people that they cannot / will not work?

Perhaps we could switch the citizenship of the employed illegals with the unemployed legally here dole people. Then the Dole people could be expelled fron Ireland.
This message has been edited - 18-jul-2012 @ 21:24
Limerick Rake
(257 Posts)
Posted: 18-Jul-2012 21:25
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Th ESRI hit the nail on the head re anyone with famalies is better off on the dole in 44% of cases ...the larger the family the more you would be better off....in the case of people with ten children you would require a wage of over 50K to justify going to work?....
Seems like people want to only give childrens allowance to travellers and increase taxs for those who persist in working?
Larkin
(4,404 Posts)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 13:50
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by ProjX:
Why cannot Dole people get a job after 3 months, when there are so many available jobs?

Just wondering if there are any jobs at your gaff helping you to sweep up of an evening. It must be the evening though cos' I generally spend the days in the Cú and bookies. Either that, or I'm doing tommers with a local builder who is also on the dole but doesn't have a full time job for me.
inbetweeners
(413 Posts)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 13:54
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Deiseallstar:
Isint it interesting that no one comes up with a recomendation to cut the wages of the big boys, those in the C.I.F Ibec, Senior Civil Servants, Bank Managers,Political Advisors that no one voted for, Failed ministers and TDs who bailed out with massive pensions and hand outs.
No calls to have our so called public Representavies who have no power or money reined in, yet they can pocket Hundrets of Thousants of Euro in wages and expences for their greedy selfs. My County Council Forked out 640.0000 between 23 Lazy Buggers last year you can multiply that by another id say 40 Local Authoritys and and see the cost of our so called political process.
We had another promise from FG/Lab to abolish the white elephant they called the senate but they backed off as if their arse were on fire.
No its easier to call for cuts in social welfare.or cut backs on the medical card as most of the above will never be so poor to qualify for either.
But bet your bottom dollar they will look for it anyway Its a rotten old Country we are now living in.

Not sure what people in IBEC and the CIF have to do with any of that.

This message has been edited - 19-jul-2012 @ 13:55
JoNinety
(Power User)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 14:18
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Limerick Rake:
the larger the family the more you would be better off....in the case of people with ten children you would require a wage of over 50K to justify going to work?....
Seems like people want to only give childrens allowance to travellers and increase taxs for those who persist in working?

How do you mean?
The person gets the children allowance for the 10 kids if he works also.
Unless you mean taking childcare costs into account, although the childcare costs for 10 kids would probably need a salary of over €100K to break even.
centreforward
(589 Posts)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 14:27
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by dubliner 2:
Child benefit for the rich (any household bringing in over €40,000 a year) is laughable.

There are about 291,000 public servants. Well over half earn less than €50,000 a year. I do not consider that to be an exhorbitant wage. But the ones at the top, social welfare and pensions all need to be tackled before those bringing home €35,000 a year or less are touched again.

So what you're saying is €50k a year is not an exorbitant wage but it puts you deep in the rich category when it comes to child benefit?

dubliner 2
(10,823 Posts)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 15:34
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by centreforward:
So what you're saying is €50k a year is not an exorbitant wage but it puts you deep in the rich category when it comes to child benefit?

An average family should comfortably be able to manage on €50,000 a year so yes, they have no need of social welfare. If someone is working they should be earning a good bit more than what's available on social welfare.




glasandbán
(2,046 Posts)
Posted: 19-Jul-2012 15:55
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by ProjX:
Dole people should get nothing after 3 months on the dole.Why cannot Dole people get a job after 3 months, when there are so many available jobs?Apparently most illegals here are employed. What's wrong with the Dole people that they cannot / will not work?Perhaps we could switch the citizenship of the employed illegals with the unemployed legally here dole people. Then the Dole people could be expelled fron Ireland.

Expanding your WUMMERY beyond the pale of Limerick hurling I see. ;)

First 1 2 Last
Select a page:   Page 1 of 2
"Speak Out!" Home  |  Topic Listing  |  Post New Topic  |  Post Reply
Content Zone
‘We talk just like lions, but we sacrifice like lambs…’.
Whatever Happened to….
Anyone you know in your club?
Bin Tags Don't Make a County
‘Some a’ Dem’ Lads are only Dow-en for the Showers….’
Heavenly Hurling: How the Gods pass their time...
GAA Time and Real Time
Saint Patrick and the camogie princesses
Keats and Chapman at the Munster Final
Mass, the Mater, ‘The Dergvale’ and Mullingar…

More "Content Zone" Topics >>


Speak Out!

More "Speak Out!" Topics >>

There are 10,277 members signed up to anfearrua.com
All times are Dublin, Ireland. Always here... with the best in GAA discussion and comment! © An Fear Rua, 2000 - 2026
Bookmark AFR  |  Make AFR your home page About Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use [ Top of Page ]