Mobile Version
|
Register
|
Login
home
|
speak out!
|
content zone archives
|
"speak out!" archives
|
vote on it
|
soap opera
|
pub crawl
|
links
|
contact us
|
search
Follow us!
Speak Out! - Gaelic Games
Notices
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
Yesterday's HOT topics
|
Today's HOT topics
| Jump to:
All Topics
First
1
2
3
4
Last
Select a page:
1
2
3
4
PageSize:
10
25
50
Page
1
of
4
Topic:
Why do great Limerick underage teams fail to deliver??????
gorgeous gus
(63 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Time and time again,serious Limerick underage hurling teams fail to shine,a serious team on paper tonight again failed to perform to their capabilities,is it poor management,is it too many matches,too much training,stage fright,lack of balls,i cant see why this team tonight and minor and under 21 teams of the last 4 years havn't won an all Ireland.
Scoreboard
(301 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:24
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Not good enough is the answer. Hannon & Dowling can't win a game on their own.Where are the other GREAT players you refer to. Downes looking like a one season wonder.
kieran73
(566 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:26
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
What made them a great team to start with ?
wrists19
(29 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:31
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by gorgeous gus:
Time and time again,serious Limerick underage hurling teams fail to shine,a serious team on paper tonight again failed to perform to their capabilities,is it poor management,is it too many matches,too much training,stage fright,lack of balls,i cant see why this team tonight and minor and under 21 teams of the last 4 years havn't won an all Ireland.
its prob because the limerick public hype em up too much!no mention of the tipp team all year and now dere in the final caus they had all the team training collectively and injuries to a few key players and the underdogs tag to keep them motivated.Whereas the limerick public were automatically assuming that because they had more senior panelists on the team that they had to only turn up.Although I wouldnt be so tough on them caus fatigue from sat prob had a lot to do with it aswel.
Harry Styles
(67 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:33
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by gorgeous gus:
Time and time again,serious Limerick underage hurling teams fail to shine,a serious team on paper tonight again failed to perform to their capabilities,is it poor management,is it too many matches,too much training,stage fright,lack of balls,i cant see why this team tonight and minor and under 21 teams of the last 4 years havn't won an all Ireland.
To answer your question we're just not good enough. Tonights performance was a prime example. Couldn't handle the favourites tag, they believed in their own hype, the local media in particular were hyping them up to the last and the result that Limerick got tonight was just what they deserved. We've a habit here in Limerick of getting carried away with ourselves after one `` Morale Boosting Victory''. We make off then that we have a damn right to win everything and once we turn up on the day everything will be grand. NONSENSE!!! If we want to be successful as a hurling county and be considered as a a Top Hurling County, we have to work as hard as every other county, Prepare as well as every other county and train as hard as every other county and not get carried away with the bit of success that comes our way. We should be driving on and have to hunger to win even more medals because thats why Kilkenny have been successful down through the years. They never rest on their laurels and are always looking to add a new dimension to their game and most of all have the hunger and the drive to succeed whereas the Limerick Lads DONT!!!
absent
(1,452 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:50
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by gorgeous gus:
Time and time again,serious Limerick underage hurling teams fail to shine,a serious team on paper tonight again failed to perform to their capabilities,is it poor management,is it too many matches,too much training,stage fright,lack of balls,i cant see why this team tonight and minor and under 21 teams of the last 4 years havn't won an all Ireland.
No team ethic,no understanding of what TEAM play is all about.
theface2010
(3,490 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:52
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
What a ridiculous topic. What makes a great underage team? Limerick U-21 10 years ago was a great underage team because they won 3 AI's. How can a team that has only played 1 match be a great team? Typical of a lot of attitudes in Limerick where people seem quicker than most to blow players up before sh1tting all over them the first chance they get.
Hitch
(3,644 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 21:56
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by theface2010:
What a ridiculous topic. What makes a great underage team? Limerick U-21 10 years ago was a great underage team because they won 3 AI's. How can a team that has only played 1 match be a great team? Typical of a lot of attitudes in Limerick where people seem quicker than most to blow players up before sh1tting all over them the first chance they get.
Just as well you edited that one Face!
theface2010
(3,490 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:08
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Hitch:
Just as well you edited that one Face!
Ha-just goes to show you should always re-read your posts Hitch! I could've been casting all sorts of aspersions there.
afunchofbucks
(339 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:11
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
the u21 grade is a tough grade to prepare for and this years limerick u21s are a prime example of this. 9 of the team as far as i know are on the senior panel- tipp on the other hand had only one senior panelist(i think). This causes major probs for the limerick management. Whereas the tipp team are nearly alwys training and playing matches together and therefore beoming a team, Limeirck rarely trained as a whole squad and dont always have a full team out for challenge matches. Therefore their teamwork or lack of it showed tonight. Your often better off not having star names at u21 and then you can work as a team throughout the year.
Bernie Peters
(412 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
like the Tipp U212 side in 2010? Nonsense argument really. The Limerick team was over hyped by apublic foaming at the mouth for some bit of success. Predicting a big win against a county like Tip is dangerous and foolish to the extreme. They rarely send out a bad team and are very difficult to beat regardless.
bully bull
(130 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Take out the word 'great' from the title and you may have a thread.
In limerick we do not have the same tradition of winning that is present in the Big Three counties. It takes an incredible amount of work to break tradition. Ths is why you have to admire Tipp for what they are doing in football. Limerick haven't had a great underage team since that u21 team of ten years ago. Our underage record is abysmal in minor and for the large part in u21 also. Our seniors haven't won a title in almost 20 years!
Perhaps this is why we go ape when we win anything like an u21 Munster or when a decent player arrives on scene, we are all willing him to do well and this places an unnecessary burden on young shoulders. Saughs comes to mind and this time around it's Hannon's turn.
I've made the point before but I'll say it again. Hannon and Maher were touted as 2 of the best young hurlers in he country when thy met in the Harty final, they prob still are. Hannon is already the main man on our senior team at 19 whereas Maher is allowed time to develop and find his feet at u21. When it's time he will graduate to senior and he might get a few league games to ease him in. Unfortunately we don't have that luxury in limerick because the quality simply isn't there yet.
No. 22
(1,694 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:27
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
politics tonight
a team consciously playing with 14 men deserves to lose
South Limerick Referee
(16,613 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 22:44
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Fringe players at senior level don't get enough game time. They arent playing with the club and they arent playing with the county. They come into a game like this and they have no proper championship match practice. Tipperary had a game played and beat Cork.
They were also used to playing as a team. As I indicated earlier today, they were a far better team than people were prepared to give then credit for with proven pedigree at minor level in beating Limerick. Limerick teams traditionally cannot handle the favourites tag either. Tipperary were deserved winners, were the more balanced even team, and only for the wides they hit could have won by an awful lot more.
A very valid point on Maher and Hannon. In the Munster club of 2009 against Newtownshandrum, Hannon scored something like 1-12 mainly from frees for Adare, and Denis Maher scored 0-6 from play in the next round for Thurles Sarsfields. The name Denis Maher has barely been mentioned since whereas the media latched onto Declan Hannon the morning after that Newtownshandrum game. The second we produce a player of above average talent, the hype machine goes overboard. That then creates unrealistic expectation. Conor Allis and Graham Mulcahy were key members of this team last year, and their replacements did not bring the same level of solidity. Pat Begley also delivered a serious performance in the Munster final, though his replacement Dan Morrissey could not be faulted.
bully bull
(130 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 23:02
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
SLR why was the 5 year plan abandoned when it proved so successful?
theblack&amber
(593 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 23:06
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by kieran73:
What made them a great team to start with ?
Good question.
Perhaps the fact they had Dowling, Downes and Hannon on the team hyped them up a bit.
capitalhurler
(333 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 23:18
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
The players don't deserve to be slated. They tried their best eventhough they fell well short.
It also must be said that young players also don't deserve to be blown up.
We have some really poor hurlers on our senior panel. That was clearly shown to the public tonight. To the people going to club matches, they would have known this for a while. Some of our players tonight could have been taken offby their clubs in the opening two rounds of the championship
rebelrebel30
(8,531 Posts)
Posted:
18-Jul-2012 23:20
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by theblack&amber:
Good question.Perhaps the fact they had Dowling, Downes and Hannon on the team hyped them up a bit.
This is the problem.
Hes'No'Relation
(365 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 01:37
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Maybe with titles with words such as 'Great Limerick underage teams' in it. There was nothing great about tonights team, we hadn't even seen them puck a ball competitively all year yet. Too hyped up as usual added to the fact Limerick teams just can't carry even the slightest favourites tag.....
phildafluter
(54 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 08:02
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
I think the expectation from the limerick support was crazy. When you hear them mention a handy win over tipp , you can start to write the obiturary ...Seriously have Tipp ever given anything up "handy" Tipp have been played down all year even tho at minor they were unlucky not to beat Kk in the 09 minor semi. Limerick had a good side last night but they were no where near GREAT . Only in Lim would a team be called great without winning squat or even pucking a ball this year. The first thing Limerick could look at is developmental structure . When ASR is seen in some quarters as a flagship for developing young limerick sides ... Under age club structures , Developmental squads , Tony Forrestal, these are far more important than one Harty cup team . The net just isn't wide enough. Harty cup sides rarely carry more than 3-4 inter county standard players and never reflect county success . Limerick could do alot worse than invest time in juvenile club development.
Hurling Veteran
(202 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 11:02
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
This result was a dose of reality. Make no mistake about it. Our supporters have been very critical of this defeat but the supporters must blame themselves for building one hit wonders into superstars and placing them on a pedestal. The mistakes of 10 years ago have not been learned. There is no drink involved now but there is similar foolishness. Unlike many supporters, I try to believe that all players gave 100% last night and there was none of this primadonna stuff that they are senior players now and do not need to bother with under 21.
Willie Griffin and Tom O'Callaghan were badly treated because they were not fashionable Ard Scoil or LSH panel names. I thought our underage squads had moved away from the politics of the situation but after a couple of things last night I am not sure. I got sucked into the hype from last year and believed we would win last night. This result in hindsight should have been predictable but we allowed ourselves to be blinded by propaganda and hype. These players have never produced at their own age playing for Limerick. It is easy for Donal O'Grady to pontificate on TG4 but he has only worked with some of these guys for one year and does not have the same experience as those who brought them up through underage.
Sean O'Brien was a disappointment and he will not make it at senior level unless he delivers consistently. WHat has he achieved since he made the LSH panel? Mark Carmody needs to revise the method in which he holds his hurley because he will not survive at senior level on his workrate alone. This is basic underage stuff. Kevin Downes had a great chance running through in the second half and when the two Tipperary defenders came across, he almost lost the ball over the end line. This is senior hurling and he needs to make up his mind. What would Richie Power or Colin Fennelly do in that situation?
Declan Hannon decided he wanted to be a graceful ball playing CB and not a marker. Tom Ryan likewise except he gets hooked and blocked too easily. Shane Dowling has not scored from play against decent opposition since he criticised the supporters in a newspaper interview. I saw a stat last week on this site where Niall Moran got 0-3 or more in 18 championship matches for Limerick. Whether Moran gets booed off the field and there has been a long standing agenda to get these guys on the LSH team ahead of him. What has Downes achieved since being left in oceans of space against Waterford? Alan Dempsey tidies things up well but how good is he to win his own battle?
It is all very fine to be a colleges star with chicks from Laurel Hill on your arm but this is mans stuff and it is not even senior hurling. Plenty of thinking for our young players to do. Do they want to be Facebook and Twitter celebs or do they want to play for Limerick. You cannot do both.
theblack&amber
(593 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 11:11
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Perhaps the reason the fail is because they're called a great U21 team before they've even pucked a ball? Also maybe because of the fact they're over-hyped from last year, even though they didn't even win the AI?
And where is this attitude coming from some that this is an average Tipp team? They've looked good so far to me, very skillful and hard-working. Over-looking the opposition is always dangerous, especially when that opposition is Tipp.
staycalm
(1,081 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 11:19
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Hurling Veteran:
This result was a dose of reality. Make no mistake about it. Our supporters have been very critical of this defeat but the supporters must blame themselves for building one hit wonders into superstars and placing them on a pedestal. The mistakes of 10 years ago have not been learned. There is no drink involved now but there is similar foolishness. Unlike many supporters, I try to believe that all players gave 100% last night and there was none of this primadonna stuff that they are senior players now and do not need to bother with under 21. Willie Griffin and Tom O'Callaghan were badly treated because they were not fashionable Ard Scoil or LSH panel names. I thought our underage squads had moved away from the politics of the situation but after a couple of things last night I am not sure. I got sucked into the hype from last year and believed we would win last night. This result in hindsight should have been predictable but we allowed ourselves to be blinded by propaganda and hype. These players have never produced at their own age playing for Limerick. It is easy for Donal O'Grady to pontificate on TG4 but he has only worked with some of these guys for one year and does not have the same experience as those who brought them up through underage. Sean O'Brien was a disappointment and he will not make it at senior level unless he delivers consistently. WHat has he achieved since he made the LSH panel? Mark Carmody needs to revise the method in which he holds his hurley because he will not survive at senior level on his workrate alone. This is basic underage stuff. Kevin Downes had a great chance running through in the second half and when the two Tipperary defenders came across, he almost lost the ball over the end line. This is senior hurling and he needs to make up his mind. What would Richie Power or Colin Fennelly do in that situation? Declan Hannon decided he wanted to be a graceful ball playing CB and not a marker. Tom Ryan likewise except he gets hooked and blocked too easily. Shane Dowling has not scored from play against decent opposition since he criticised the supporters in a newspaper interview. I saw a stat last week on this site where Niall Moran got 0-3 or more in 18 championship matches for Limerick. Whether Moran gets booed off the field and there has been a long standing agenda to get these guys on the LSH team ahead of him. What has Downes achieved since being left in oceans of space against Waterford? Alan Dempsey tidies things up well but how good is he to win his own battle? It is all very fine to be a colleges star with chicks from Laurel Hill on your arm but this is mans stuff and it is not even senior hurling. Plenty of thinking for our young players to do. Do they want to be Facebook and Twitter celebs or do they want to play for Limerick. You cannot do both.
Talking sh!t as usual. Comparing Downes to Richie Power. Richie Power is 26 years of age. Downes is 20. And the Laurel Hill sh!t doesnt even derserve a response.
Snoop99
(234 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 11:53
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
When it was necessary to move hannon to no 6 it should have been a warning sign for Limerick supporters that this u21 team may no be all it was cracked up to be. Outside of the Hannon, Downes and Dowling and the other senior panelists the remainder of the team was pretty moderate. Tipp while having no super stars they had much more balance to their team and had a far better attitude. Ken Hogan is a wily and experienced manager and is getting the maximum out of his players and squad, Tipp were better prepared and seemed much fitter than Limerick on the night.
This is a big setback for Limerick, an extended run in the u21 grade would have been a good platform to further player development. Going out of the championship at the first hurdle leaves only a negative experience in the players minds, even a 2/3 match run would have helped to bring on players enormously, the value of an extra month or more coaching and training for players at this age is huge.
An fear glas agus dubh
(892 Posts)
Posted:
19-Jul-2012 11:56
Quote
Edit
Delete
Report Post
Post Reply
Originally posted by Hurling Veteran:
This result was a dose of reality. Make no mistake about it. Our supporters have been very critical of this defeat but the supporters must blame themselves for building one hit wonders into superstars and placing them on a pedestal. The mistakes of 10 years ago have not been learned. There is no drink involved now but there is similar foolishness. Unlike many supporters, I try to believe that all players gave 100% last night and there was none of this primadonna stuff that they are senior players now and do not need to bother with under 21. Willie Griffin and Tom O'Callaghan were badly treated because they were not fashionable Ard Scoil or LSH panel names. I thought our underage squads had moved away from the politics of the situation but after a couple of things last night I am not sure. I got sucked into the hype from last year and believed we would win last night. This result in hindsight should have been predictable but we allowed ourselves to be blinded by propaganda and hype. These players have never produced at their own age playing for Limerick. It is easy for Donal O'Grady to pontificate on TG4 but he has only worked with some of these guys for one year and does not have the same experience as those who brought them up through underage. Sean O'Brien was a disappointment and he will not make it at senior level unless he delivers consistently. WHat has he achieved since he made the LSH panel? Mark Carmody needs to revise the method in which he holds his hurley because he will not survive at senior level on his workrate alone. This is basic underage stuff. Kevin Downes had a great chance running through in the second half and when the two Tipperary defenders came across, he almost lost the ball over the end line. This is senior hurling and he needs to make up his mind. What would Richie Power or Colin Fennelly do in that situation? Declan Hannon decided he wanted to be a graceful ball playing CB and not a marker. Tom Ryan likewise except he gets hooked and blocked too easily. Shane Dowling has not scored from play against decent opposition since he criticised the supporters in a newspaper interview. I saw a stat last week on this site where Niall Moran got 0-3 or more in 18 championship matches for Limerick. Whether Moran gets booed off the field and there has been a long standing agenda to get these guys on the LSH team ahead of him. What has Downes achieved since being left in oceans of space against Waterford? Alan Dempsey tidies things up well but how good is he to win his own battle? It is all very fine to be a colleges star with chicks from Laurel Hill on your arm but this is mans stuff and it is not even senior hurling. Plenty of thinking for our young players to do. Do they want to be Facebook and Twitter celebs or do they want to play for Limerick. You cannot do both.
What an utter pile of nonsense. Dowling hasn’t scored from Play against decent opposition since his newspaper article, They have had one decent game since that article. The lad looks absolutely exhausted. He has been nonstop hurling for the last year. It really bugs me when people like yourself post snide remarks about players personal lives. Inter county hurlers have lives outside hurling. Dempsey was one of the few Limerick hurlers to play well last night. I take it your weren’t at Na Pairsaigh vs Crusheen. Well have a look at the tape and see how good his to win his own battle. You don’t realise it but you are worse that any of the Limerick fans who overhyped teams. Way overboard in the criticism and the usual bullsh1t of “oh they are more after the fame than Hurling”. They didn’t play well last night but Tipp had all the hall marks of a team that has played and trained together all year. Limerick looked disjointed and disorganised
First
1
2
3
4
Last
Select a page:
1
2
3
4
Page
1
of
4
"Speak Out!" Home
|
Topic Listing
|
Post New Topic
|
Post Reply
‘We talk just like lions, but we sacrifice like lambs…’.
Whatever Happened to….
Anyone you know in your club?
Bin Tags Don't Make a County
‘Some a’ Dem’ Lads are only Dow-en for the Showers….’
Heavenly Hurling: How the Gods pass their time...
GAA Time and Real Time
Saint Patrick and the camogie princesses
Keats and Chapman at the Munster Final
Mass, the Mater, ‘The Dergvale’ and Mullingar…
More "Content Zone" Topics >>
More "Speak Out!" Topics >>