Mobile Version  |  Register  |  Login
home  |  speak out!  |  content zone archives  |  "speak out!" archives  |  vote on it  |  soap opera  |  pub crawl  |  links  |  contact us  |  search  
 Follow us! 
Speak Out! - Gaelic Games
Notices
"Speak Out!" Home  |  Topic Listing  |  Post New Topic  |  Post Reply
Yesterday's HOT topics  |  Today's HOT topics
 |  Jump to:  
First 1 2 Last
Select a page:   PageSize:   Page 1 of 2
Topic: 5.8.2012 - The Day the Music Died for The Kerry Team ?
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 06-Aug-2012 20:51
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Many regarded Martin Carney's comments during the Cork V Kerry game, as being premature.

However, this subject must be re-visitied now - Have we seen the passing of the 2nd best IC Football Team of all-time?

The current Kerry Team are undoubedly one of the best teams ever, 2nd only to Mick O Dwyer's great team - in the opinion of many.

However, many of their marquee names such as Darragh O Se & Tom O Sullivan have already retired and will surely soon be followed by such greats as Tomas & Marc O Se, Eoin Brosnan, Aidan O Mahony and Paul Galvin. Colm 'Gooch' Cooper and Declan O Sullivan will be 30 next Summer and both have a lot of milage already on the clock.

The notion that Kerry's great run of success has come to an end is supported by the relative lack of success at underage with a sole u21 title in 2008 and the last Minor triumph in 1994.

Most Football Supporters will have enjoyed seeing this team at it's best and would mourn it's passing - if indeed, last Sunday was the day the music finally died.
cerebus
(3,258 Posts)
Posted: 06-Aug-2012 21:01
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Yerra we haven't thrown in the towel or the banana, yet!!

corcaighabu92
(1,149 Posts)
Posted: 06-Aug-2012 21:34
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
More than likely but hopefully not. What a team they have been. Tomas O'Se is 34, he will surely go now. Aidan O'Mahony had a good year this year but what age is he. Would love to see Tomas stay but I think he and Brosnan will retire stay. The rest of them have a bit left in them yet. Maybe a change of manager could regnite this group of players.
Roberto Jordan
(825 Posts)
Posted: 06-Aug-2012 21:44
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by JackMurphy:
Many regarded Martin Carney's comments during the Cork V Kerry game, as being premature.However, this subject must be re-visitied now - Have we seen the passing of the 2nd best IC Football Team of all-time?The current Kerry Team are undoubedly one of the best teams ever, 2nd only to Mick O Dwyer's great team - in the opinion of many.However, many of their marquee names such as Darragh O Se & Tom O Sullivan have already retired and will surely soon be followed by such greats as Tomas & Marc O Se, Eoin Brosnan, Aidan O Mahony and Paul Galvin. Colm 'Gooch' Cooper and Declan O Sullivan will be 30 next Summer and both have a lot of milage already on the clock.

The notion that Kerry's great run of success has come to an end is supported by the relative lack of success at underage with a sole u21 title in 2008 and the last Minor triumph in 1994.Most Football Supporters will have enjoyed seeing this team at it's best and would mourn it's passing - if indeed, last Sunday was the day the music finally died.

After 15 years since the Maurice Fitz final against Mayo this is the first time they have had quite so many question marks about them. They ran out of road yesterday.

However they are just as likley to re-emerge in 1 or 2 years with a core of current team along with 4 or 5 more as they are to enter a sustained period of rebuilding. They certainly wont go through the same 10 year lulll as in teh nineties , if only because of teh back door system.

But hard to see them being all ireland favourites or near it next year, despite the small number of actual contenders.

dont forget that Dublin still only have one truely top scoring forward and who knows how the vast young talent in the cork pnael will fare as the older heads shuffle off the scene in next while ( though this is probably only Noelie, Canty , pearse o neil and nicholas murphy)

History doesnt mean much but it says that of the 3 traditional big teams who appear to need a lot re-building of (kerry , galway, meath) and of the recent top sides who also need to do so ( armagh, tyrone) that Kerry are the most likley to back on the steps of the Hogan again first................

rebelrebel30
(8,531 Posts)
Posted: 06-Aug-2012 23:03
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by JackMurphy:
Many regarded Martin Carney's comments during the Cork V Kerry game, as being premature.However, this subject must be re-visitied now - Have we seen the passing of the 2nd best IC Football Team of all-time?The current Kerry Team are undoubedly one of the best teams ever, 2nd only to Mick O Dwyer's great team - in the opinion of many.However, many of their marquee names such as Darragh O Se & Tom O Sullivan have already retired and will surely soon be followed by such greats as Tomas & Marc O Se, Eoin Brosnan, Aidan O Mahony and Paul Galvin. Colm 'Gooch' Cooper and Declan O Sullivan will be 30 next Summer and both have a lot of milage already on the clock.

The notion that Kerry's great run of success has come to an end is supported by the relative lack of success at underage with a sole u21 title in 2008 and the last Minor triumph in 1994.Most Football Supporters will have enjoyed seeing this team at it's best and would mourn it's passing - if indeed, last Sunday was the day the music finally died.

I would never have thought of Aidan O Mahony as good as those other mentioned players for Kerry, he wasnt that bad but i wouldnt have him in same class as Tomas O Shea, Eoin Brosnan, Declan O Sullivan etc.
kavvie
(289 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 05:41
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
as bad as kerry were and despite being crippled by injurys during the donegal game they shoud have got a free at the end to draw it(undeserved but thems the facts).id say tomas will go.lots left in the rest of them though..declan o sullivan and gooch will be there for at least 4/5 yrs more id say?
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 08:22
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by kavvie:
as bad as kerry were and despite being crippled by injurys during the donegal game they shoud have got a free at the end to draw it(undeserved but thems the facts).id say tomas will go.lots left in the rest of them though..declan o sullivan and gooch will be there for at least 4/5 yrs more id say?

Many people are saying that Donegal deserved the victory. I think that Kerry were desperately unlucky. Injuries robbed them of key players at crucial times :-

Bryan Sheehan - struggled for most of 2nd half and Kerry missed a free that he would have slotted, minutes after he went off.

Eoin Brosnan - A key player in a pivotal position.

Darren O Sullivan - Injury ruined his preparation and limited his involvement and effectiveness - has been key for Kerry in recent years.

Colm Cooper - injured for last 15 minutes - missing him and Declan O Sullivan in that vital time was crucial.

David Moran - Not mentioned at all - would have been a big player for Kerry this year.

Injuries meant that the key chance to equalise fell to an inexperiened played - Paddy Curtin.

Kerry were also unfortunate to concede a crucial goal at exactly the wrong time - this settled Donegal and was perfect for their game plan. Teams must bring a MF'er back for these plays with the new rule creating problems for GK'ers.

Kerry have lost 3 knock-out games at CP now - all by less than a score and all games they could and probably should have won.

Reports suggest that Jack O Connor will step down but none of the players will retire - a new management team featuring E FitzMaurice and Donie Buckley could re-invigorate Kerry for one final tilt next year.

Don't rule out one more AI for this team.
This message has been edited - 07-aug-2012 @ 08:25
Donohill
(732 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 08:39
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Anyone like to speculate on who might fill the gaps in the next few years for Kerry? I've seen a good few of Kerry's recent underage teams from playing against Tipp and I'd be interested in the Kerry boys' opinions.
Buttofthehill
(421 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 08:59
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
This felt like a missed opportunity for Kerry in the end. It was very close and was lost in the first half despite all the injuries and other disadvantages coming in the second. The stodginess with the ball going forward was remarkable - really really obvious and mentioned by Tomas o flaithearta at half time. Their backs kept them in it. Middle did well at getting ball but miserable at moving it. Ive never seen such poor ball in to forwards
One thing I did notice over about fifteen years looking at this team in croke park is that whenever they are beaten it is by a team with the energy and confidence to break forward in packs and forget about where the Kerry players are. They only exception being Dublin who beat them in much the same way Kerry would have beaten them.
Hope to see them get some form back - this was the best match of the weekend even with Kerry's confusion and I'd be of the mindset that I'd prefer to see good football. I think Donegal played the better football when they had the ball btw just ignoring that as this is a "kerry" thread.
This message has been edited - 07-aug-2012 @ 09:00
Chucky
(67 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 09:17
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
As a Corkman I would be delighted if the suggestion above that all the older players are planning on staying on. I think this would be a repeat of the mistake Kerry made in the late 80's when the likes of Paidi O'Se, Bomber etc refused to go quietly into the night.

For example i've seen a lot of Peter Crowley playing with UCC over the past 2 years and he seems to be the real deal but isn't getting a look in. If Kerry persist with Tomás O'Se and Brosnan, great players though they were, ahead of youngsters like that then they'll be set for another fallow period.

Either way i think it'll be a long time before they dominate again but with the quality of players they have they'll always be contenders at least. If nothing else, most counties would kill to have the options of Maher, Sheehan and Moran (hopefully for his sake) to choose from at midfield.
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 10:05
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Chucky:
As a Corkman I would be delighted if the suggestion above that all the older players are planning on staying on. I think this would be a repeat of the mistake Kerry made in the late 80's when the likes of Paidi O'Se, Bomber etc refused to go quietly into the night. For example i've seen a lot of Peter Crowley playing with UCC over the past 2 years and he seems to be the real deal but isn't getting a look in. If Kerry persist with Tomás O'Se and Brosnan, great players though they were, ahead of youngsters like that then they'll be set for another fallow period. Either way i think it'll be a long time before they dominate again but with the quality of players they have they'll always be contenders at least. If nothing else, most counties would kill to have the options of Maher, Sheehan and Moran (hopefully for his sake) to choose from at midfield.

Replacing great players is a very tricky issue. How do you drop Tomas O Se ? and how can a young lad come in and play to his level, immediatly. As Paudie O Se once famously stated - Kerry supporters are not known for their patience.

A huge issue for Kerry is that Declan O Sullivan, Colm Cooper and Kieran Donaghy will all be over 30 when Kerry play COrk in next year's Munster C/ship. Galvin will be 34 next year - Acknowledged as the best forward unit in the modern era - with all their achievements - can these lads find the motivation to stay at the top with the current demands.

It's unlikely that Kerry will win an AI for the next 3 years - that amounts to a famine in the Kingdom.
turncoat
(489 Posts)
Posted: 07-Aug-2012 10:06
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
In both games Kerry lost in chmapionship Tom O Se to me was the one kerry players still going til the death in both games.Regardless of his age he has serious fitness and defo has the legs for more years.
This message has been edited - 07-aug-2012 @ 10:07
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 11:50
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Reports suggesting that Jack O Connor has decided not to remain on for the final year of his term.

A new man will surely look to rebuild - starting next season.

You don't get much time in Kerry and with the famine now in it's third year - the new manager will be expected to deliver Sam by 2014.

He'll need to get a few new lads in for next season - he'll want to retain a few experienced lads but will have big calls to makee on Brosnan, O Mahony, Galvin, the 2 O Se's etc.

Can't see Kerry win Sam in 2013 and Cooper, Declan O Sullivan and Donaghy will be 31 plus by 2014 - with all the running required by forwards now - It's no country for old men.
carryharry
(4,804 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 11:55
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
If Jack O'Connor steps down, who would be a suitable replacement????
frasiercrane
(1,843 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 13:40
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by carryharry:
If Jack O'Connor steps down, who would be a suitable replacement????

Pat Spillane.He seems to know exatly what every manager in teh country is doing wrong
thehermit
(1,143 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 14:42
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
'Listen, asthore, for these eyes are sealed,
Listen once more, when Kerrymen take the field,
Tell an old man who saw them in days of old,
Do they walk proudly in their green and gold?

Listen, asthore, when Kerry take the field,
Tell me when they attack and when they yield;
Say if they fail; asthore, I'm blind and old,
Tell me they'll not dishonour the green and gold.'

Maybe for a short while we will have to see the likes of Dublin and Cork winning a couple of titles, but winter will always give way eventually to spring. The light of our tradition, of our famous victories will forever shine as long as men kick a ball in this country. Sometimes beaten but never unbowed: An Riocht, as ever, Abu!!
Donohill
(732 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 15:16
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Kerry have only won 1 Munster U21 in the last 10 years. Interesting stat. Whatever about All Ireland success that's a poor enough return at provincial level.

I'm sure they'll be back and I hope they are, as they have some great stylists, as opposed to just machines.
This message has been edited - 08-aug-2012 @ 15:16
rebelrising
(484 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 15:22
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by thehermit:
'Listen, asthore, for these eyes are sealed,
Listen once more, when Kerrymen take the field,
Tell an old man who saw them in days of old,
Do they walk proudly in their green and gold?Listen, asthore, when Kerry take the field,
Tell me when they attack and when they yield;
Say if they fail; asthore, I'm blind and old,
Tell me they'll not dishonour the green and gold.'Maybe for a short while we will have to see the likes of Dublin and Cork winning a couple of titles, but winter will always give way eventually to spring. The light of our tradition, of our famous victories will forever shine as long as men kick a ball in this country. Sometimes beaten but never unbowed: An Riocht, as ever, Abu!!

A crime to poetry. there might be a silver lining in kerry hermit..hurling may prosper.
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 15:36
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by carryharry:
If Jack O'Connor steps down, who would be a suitable replacement????

The Kerry CB will try hard to persuade Jack to remain for the final year of his term. But Jack is more likely to persuade the older guys to give one last lash - than do a clear-out & start re-building. Catch 22.

However, both Jack and Eamon FitzMaurice know that rebuilding in Kerry is a thankless task. It requires major surgery because so many are 29 ond older. Not many of those will be there in 3 years which is the time frame that managers will require.

However, Paudie O Se has told us what to expect from Kerry Supporters and it's not patience.

FitzMaurice wants the job in 2 or 3 years - the problem is where to find a fall guy 'til then.

Muilleann
(61 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 15:49
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
This Kerry team grew from a successful U21 team managed by Paidi O'Se.

Think same will have to happen again.

Fine footballing team Kerry but they got a few soft ones on the way (and good luck to them) and,as Brolly said,could never handle the Northern teams who "looked them in the eye" or indeed the Meath team of the early noughties who put them to the sword.
JackMurphy
(254 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 17:07
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Muilleann:
This Kerry team grew from a successful U21 team managed by Paidi O'Se.Think same will have to happen again.Fine footballing team Kerry but they got a few soft ones on the way (and good luck to them) and,as Brolly said,could never handle the Northern teams who "looked them in the eye" or indeed the Meath team of the early noughties who put them to the sword.

Kerry's success in recent years has been underpinned by the O Se brothers and a great set of forwards.

If it takes 3 years or so to build a good side - all of the O Se's will be gone and probably Cooper, Declan O Sullivan and Donaghy. It's going to be very hard for Kerry to find the calibre of player to fill those boots as there has been no success at underage.

You can never write Kerry off but the signs don't look good right now. Cork have plenty of scores to settle and would love to give Kerry some decent trimmings in the next few years.
carryharry
(4,804 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 17:16
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
If Jack does go, would John Evans not be an option with FitzMaurice as co manager?

I know he is not noted as a bigtime Intercounty manager but his experience with Tipperary underage teams must give him a reasonable knowledge of Kerry underage players.

Whatever is said about him, he changed the mindset in Tipp and was highly regarded.

I believe he did well with clubs in Kerry too but that would be the height of my knowledge of that.
cerebus
(3,258 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 19:30
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by Muilleann:
Fine footballing team Kerry but they got a few soft ones on the way (and good luck to them)

Yerra if they were soft sure the other counties could have won them too.

carryharry
(4,804 Posts)
Posted: 08-Aug-2012 19:53
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by cerebus:
Yerra if they were soft sure the other counties could have won them too.

They must be replica's if they are soft Bus!
Muilleann
(61 Posts)
Posted: 09-Aug-2012 11:19
Quote   Edit   Delete   Report Post   Post Reply
Originally posted by carryharry:
If Jack does go, would John Evans not be an option with FitzMaurice as co manager?I know he is not noted as a bigtime Intercounty manager but his experience with Tipperary underage teams must give him a reasonable knowledge of Kerry underage players.Whatever is said about him, he changed the mindset in Tipp and was highly regarded.I believe he did well with clubs in Kerry too but that would be the height of my knowledge of that.

A lot of football people in Tipp were not too enamoured of Evans and were glad to see him go.


First 1 2 Last
Select a page:   Page 1 of 2
"Speak Out!" Home  |  Topic Listing  |  Post New Topic  |  Post Reply
Content Zone
‘We talk just like lions, but we sacrifice like lambs…’.
Whatever Happened to….
Anyone you know in your club?
Bin Tags Don't Make a County
‘Some a’ Dem’ Lads are only Dow-en for the Showers….’
Heavenly Hurling: How the Gods pass their time...
GAA Time and Real Time
Saint Patrick and the camogie princesses
Keats and Chapman at the Munster Final
Mass, the Mater, ‘The Dergvale’ and Mullingar…

More "Content Zone" Topics >>


Speak Out!

More "Speak Out!" Topics >>

There are 10,277 members signed up to anfearrua.com
All times are Dublin, Ireland. Always here... with the best in GAA discussion and comment! © An Fear Rua, 2000 - 2013
Bookmark AFR  |  Make AFR your home page About Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use [ Top of Page ]